This practice is extremely well documented, yet it has hardly ever been mentioned as an important method of primitive accumulation. Primitive accumulation and the capitalist mode of production. In marxist economics and preceding theories, 1 the problem of primitive accumulation also previous accumulation, original accumulation of capital concerns the origin of capital, and therefore in at least the marxist view of how class distinctions between possessors and nonpossessors came to be. As competition is capitals very essence, however, accumulation as we shall. It appears as primitive, because it forms the prehistoric stage of capital and of the mode of production corresponding with it. Primitive accumulation of capital was the term marx used to describe the accumulation of the social and economic conditions from which capitalism arose. In the first place, part viii is a lot easier to read, being less abstract and richer with historical detail. May 05, 2018 primitive accumulation of capital is alive and well karl marxs fundamental contribution is to show that the propensity to produce and sell goods for profit is not the natural selfinterested and greedy condition of human beings, but a result of historical transformation which produces a social structure conducive to capitalism. The accumulation of capital, probably the best book produced by a marxist and socialist thinker since karl marxs opus magnum, emerged from her sudden revelation. Primitive accumulation of capital is the process in which a ruling class takes possession of land and thereby converts the resident population into a landless proletariat.
Primitive accumulation of capital article about primitive. Capital accumulation is the growth in wealth through investments or profits. Migrant labour and the process of primitive accumulation. Then in the english translation of the english translation of capital. It is not just the book volume i, that are found on other websites, nor an online version where you have to scroll through endless pages in your browser, rather this is volume i, ii and iii in one book in a downloadable format. Give some examples of cultures which were mostly, or entirely destroyed. When capital cannot rely on its normal systemic processes to ensure its access to resources, it uses violent means to do so. Primitive accumulation of capital is alive and well karl marxs fundamental contribution is to show that the propensity to produce and sell goods for profit is not the natural selfinterested and greedy condition of human beings, but a result of historical transformation which produces a social structure conducive to capitalism. Primitive accumulation and capitalist accumulation. It appears as primitive because it forms the prehistory of capital, and of the mode of production corresponding to capital. Apr 26, 2010 further, the public debt becomes one of the most powerful levers of primitive accumulation p. Primitive accumulation, new enclosures, and global land grabs.
Accumulation by dispossession is a process of ongoing capital accumulation where a give resource is privatized, seized, or in some other manner alienated from common ownership in order to provide. What is primitive accumulation and how is it different. In germany, therefore, the capitalist mode of production came to a head, after its antagonistic character had already, in france and england, shown itself in a fierce strife of classes. It is with these assumptions and this theoretical framework in mind that in this essay, i analyze globalization as a process of primitive accumulation, this. Primitive accumulation, new enclosures, and global land. Apr 29, 2015 as this author has pointed out the process of primitive or primary accumulation the creation of capitalism out of feudalism or other traditional modes of production has never been free of force, contrary to the smithian myth, so the job of the state or global substitutes for it is to manage that force as a public good moore 2004a. The foundation for the primitive accumulation of capital was. For companies, capital accumulation can signal preparation for growth. He argues that the capitalist mode of production requires that people be forced to work in valueadding production for someone else. Primitive or original accumulation, then, is the forcible and violent process by which the capitalist system forcibly seizes resources for the sake of enabling the process of capital accumulation.
Imperialism and capitalist development in marxs capital. In capital and elsewhere marx was primarily concerned with this process as it affected europe, and particularly england, the birthplace of the capitalist mode of production. Primitive accumulation is therefore notjust a historical past from which capitalist. A distinct approach away from lenin, tuganbaranowsky, and hilferding was undertaken by rosa luxemburg, whose the accumulation of capital 19 had a major, albeit controversial, impact. According to marx, the whole purpose of primitive accumulation is to privatize the means of production, so that the exploiting owners can make money from the surplus labour of those who, lacking other means, must work for them.
Further, the public debt becomes one of the most powerful levers of primitive accumulation p. I argue that the current scholarship is limited by a certain functionalism in its theorization of ongoing primitive accumulation. On primitive accumulation, globalization and reproduction. From primitive accumulation to regimes of dispossession. Primitive accumulation of capital is the process in which a ruling class takes possession of land and thereby converts the resident population into a. The character of these preconditions is derived from the concept of capital, understood to be the process whereby money is invested in the purchase of. In capital, smiths concept of original accumulation appeared as a word that could mean either original or primitive. Economists have used the term accumulation of capital to express several conceptual ideas in economics. The socalled primitive accumulation, therefore, is nothing else than the historical process of divorcing the producer from the means of production. Mar 08, 2018 in this video, i explain in the easiest and funniest way possible what primitive accumulation is according to karl marx. Imperialism and capitalist development in marxs capital lucia pradella university of venice, ca foscari. Socalled primitive accumulation, therefore, is nothing else than the historical process of divorcing the producer from the means of production.
The term primitive accumulation or original accumulation, was originally used by the classical economists in reference to the process by which, in the mists of time, capital had been originally accumulated by an owning class distinct from laborers adam smiths accumulation of stock. Aug 05, 2005 it is in fact this divorce between the conditions of labour on the one hand and the producers on the other that forms the concept of capital, as this arises with primitive accumulation. Another aspect of the primitive accumulation of capital was the transformation of the usurped means of production into capital, and the formation of the bourgeoisie. The urban process under planetary accumulation by dispossession. Jan 18, 2020 capital accumulation is the growth in wealth through investments or profits. The continuous character of capital s enclosures find, read and cite all the research you need on. Capital accumulation also termed the accumulation of capital is the dynamic that motivates the pursuit of profit, involving the investment of money or any financial asset with the goal of increasing the initial monetary value of said asset as a financial return whether in the form of profit, rent, interest, royalties or capital gains. These changes are connected to the neoliberalization process, and characteristic of the countries of eastern and southeastern europe. It is in fact this divorce between the conditions of labour on the one hand and the producers on the other that forms the concept of capital, as this arises with primitive accumulation. The character of these preconditions is derived from the concept of capital, understood to be the process whereby money is invested. The theory of primitive accumulation takes the idealized memory of an individual capitalists accumulationsaving money, which itself is a morally coded, or best case, ideological presentation of accumulation within capitalism, and turns it into the conditions of capitalist accumulation in general.
The colonial wars and the ferocious exploitation of the populations of the captured colonies were powerful factors accelerating the process of primitive accumulation. This volume was the first of only two substantial books with the words accumulation of capital as the title, both written by women economists. The chapters of part i, which deal with value and money, tend to be very abstract and terse. Having analyzed the anatomy of the capitalist mode of production, marx had turned his attention towards the end of capital volume i to the question of how this mode of production had at all come into being. The secret of primitive accumulation 815 is nothing else than the historical process of divorcing the producer from the means of production. Such debt has given rise to stock exchange gambling and the modern bankocracy. Chapter fourprimitive accumulation and the rise of. Primitive accumulation and the restructuring of social reproduction in the global economy.
Avoiding those having to do with obtaining more money, more bonds, or more stocks, two principal uses remain. Primitive accumulation and the capitalist mode of production introduction the relationship between theory and history has long been a problem for marxists. Therefore, it appears that the capitalist mode of production as a historical formation presupposes some original or primitive accumulation. In the history of primitive accumulation, all revolutions are epochmaking that act as levers for the capital class in course of formation. The concept of primitive accumulation of capital communist. Primitive accumulation was a process to pave way for the capitalistic system that highly depends on the peasants workforce.
It is with these assumptions and this theoretical framework in mind that in this essay, i analyze globalization as a process of primitive accumulation, this time imposed on a global scale. And here he had introduced his concept of primitive. There is the emergence of a brood of bankocrats, financiers, rentiers the international credit system functions as a part of primitive accumulation. Primitive accumulation is not just the historical starting point of capitalism, but, qua coercive proletarianization, central to its essence. Apr 16, 20 in capital, smiths concept of original accumulation appeared as a word that could mean either original or primitive. Since it seems peculiar to call an ongoing process primitive or original, harvey 2003, 144. The primitive or original accumulation of capital is a concept developed in karl marxs capital and grundrisse to designate that process which generates the preconditions of the ongoing accumulation of capital. Such a reevaluation requires, first of all, a change in terminology. Marxs worst tendencies as a writer come out in force, bogging down in arid theoretical presentations and interminable algebraic calculations, with little of the literary flair and almost none of the demonstrative examples that characterize capital, vol. The economic structure of capitalist society has grown out of. For investors, capital accumulation can signal interest in an acquisition or in becoming active in the companys management.
Written by a workingclass revolutionary leader who begins by critically analyzing marxs draft volume 2 of capital and ends by relating to militarism, luxemburg develops a theoretical foundation for the global drive. The use of force and violence were the mechanisms to force the process of primitive accumulation by the colonial authorities. In fact marx argues that the original or primitive accumulation of capital often occurs through violence, plunder, slavery, robbery, extortion and theft. Primitive accumulation of capital is alive and well the. This article looks at the changes that occurred in the city of varna in relation to the primitive accumulation of capital as a precondition for new forms of capitalist social, economic and cultural relations. At any given time, the accumulation of capital depends on some already existing capital to invest in the production process. Part viii socalled primitive accumulation we begin with part viii of capital instead of part i for two reasons. It constitutes a specific mode of social labor and it is this mode of labor that forms the concept of capital.
Accumulation by dispossession as a key apparatus of capital accumulation, based around the system of centralisation and concentration of power, finds its social, political and geographical expression in the production of urban space. Accumulation by dispossession the processes that marx, following adam smith, referred to as primitive or original accumulation con stitute, in arendts view, an important and continuing force in the historical geography of capital accumulation through imperialism. Pdf primitive accumulation and capitalist accumulation. The concept of capital reflects the tendency of the capital of the leading states towards universal dominance.
The accumulation of capital the accumulation of capital is arguably the most important advance on marxs political economy to date. But in tthis process, the received marxian categories proved inadequate. Primitive accumulation of capital the forcible process by which the masses of direct producers above all, the peasants are transformed into wage laborers, and the means of production and monetary wealth into capital. Thus, the period of primitive accumulation was one which required active intervention and innovation through modern state structures and forms of what foucault called discipline, through the establishment of an explicit, coded and. For these investors, the accumulation takes place over time so as to do so quietly and without driving up the price of the shares suddenly. And meanwhile, moreover, the german proletariat had attained a much more clear classconsciousness than the german bourgeoisie. Means to grow wealth can include appreciation, rent, capital gains, and interest. I also make clear how was it done the first accumulation of capital ever. Instead, harvey maintains that primitive accumulation accumulation by dispossession is a continuing process within the process of capital accumulation on a world scale.
Only in the last option would primitive accumulation be ongoing under capitalism. More recent scholarship, inspired by rosa luxemburg, has held that ongoing primitive accumulation is indispensable for capitals expanded reproduction, which depends on the capitalist domains. Primitive accumulation and progress in southeast asia. It constitutes a specific mode of social labor and it.
208 914 267 115 803 1245 427 1225 1200 1061 574 43 1462 149 435 1439 850 1212 170 120 261 1015 1397 739 1522 44 81 56 635 312 1400 296 160 825 1297 475 908 1160 1255 211 1364 676